Jenna Bush Hager Teases Carson Daly About His Famous Exes on the ‘Today’ Show

• Jenna Bush Hager teased her Today show co-host, Carson Daly, about his famous ex-girlfriends on the Thursday, May 1 episode of the show
• Bush Hager brought up Jennifer Love Hewitt, who dated Daly in 1998, and his ex-fiancée Tara Reid, to whom Daly was linked between 2000 and 2001
• “Oh my gosh, you didn’t,” Daly said as Bush Hager and fellow co-host Savannah Guthrie played the viral TikTok game “I’m so hungry, I could eat…”

Jenna Bush Hager is getting personal with her Today show co-host, Carson Daly.

During the show on Thursday, May 1, the television personality was discussing the viral TikTok prank “I’m so hungry, I could eat…” — a game in which the participant then names a person their fellow player may find uncomfortable discussing.

Feeling in a mischievous mood, Bush Hager, 43, said, “I’m so hungry I could eat a Jennifer Love Hewitt,” referencing Daly’s ex.

Caught off guard, Daly, 23, stuttered, “Right, wait… what?” in reply, before Savannah Guthrie, 53, quipped, “Thank you for doing what I was about to do.” 

Daly — who dated the I Know What You Did Last Summer actress in 1998 — then asked for a “new seat,” before jokingly telling his co-hosts that the game was “ridiculous.”

However, Guthrie and Bush Hager weren’t done there as they proceeded to bring up actress Tara Reid, who was engaged to Daly in 2000 before the pair split in 2001.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

“What’s the other one?” Guthrie asked as Bush Hager replied, “Tara Reid!”

“Oh my gosh, you didn’t,” joked Daly as he closed out the show by backing away from his co-hosts. “We did!” mom of three Bush Hager concluded with a laugh. 

Daly has been married to Siri Pinter since 2015. The couple shares son Jackson and daughters Etta, London and Goldie.

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

In a behind-the-scenes clip shared on the Today show’s Instagram account after the show, Bush Hager and Guthrie revelled in their on-screen prank on Daly, calling it “an amazing moment for us and for the show.”

While Bush Hager said that she’d like to give “some credit” to Guthrie for the joke, her co-host praised Bush Hager for “bringing up Carson’s old girlfriends and, in some cases, fiancées.”

“Bring it here, queen,” quipped Guthrie, putting her hands up for a high five from her colleague.

The PEOPLE App is now available in the Apple App Store! Download it now for the most binge-worthy celeb content, exclusive video clips, astrology updates and more!

The Today co-hosts enjoy playing pranks on one another, as Bush Hager and Daly proved when they participated in the recently revitalized ice bucket challenge during the April 21 episode of the show. 

Bush Hager explained that the 2014 challenge, which raised money for ALS research, had been revitalized in a new TikTok campaign from students at the University of South Carolina. The correspondent then proved herself to be a great sport as she took a soaking from a delighted-looking Daly. 

“I was told they weren’t going to do too much water!” she gasped, seemingly shocked by the freezing water. However, the daughter of former President George W. Bush and first lady Laura Bush got her revenge while out on the Today Show Plaza later in the episode, pouring water on both Daly and Guthrie.